Chief Inspector Lestrade was convinced that he had his man. Sitting opposite him in the interview room, Albert Finch acted like he was already consigned to his fate. Thin, pale and sweating, he had ample motive for the murder of his employer, the pawnbroker Josiah Crabtree, and the opportunity to do it.
No need to call in help from Baker Street for this case, he would have it all wrapped up by lunch and the report done by the end of the day.
There was just the small matter of his alibi.
“I tell you it wasn’t me,” said Finch miserably. “I left Mr Crabtree in the shop at 8 o’clock, as normal and walked home. He was counting the day’s takings and then he said he was going to have an early night, on account of it being the start of the week.”
“And I suppose you expect me to believe that do you Finch?” Lestrade replied. “The cash box at the pawnbrokers was left empty and your landlady says you were behind with the rent for weeks until you suddenly paid-up last night.”
“I’d been stringing her along a bit, I admit that”, he said. “But I was waiting for a friend to pay back the money I’d loaned them. Once they did, I was able to make up my arrears.”
Suddenly, he leaned back in his chair and brightened up a bit.
“And I had a fish supper last night to celebrate on the way home as well. Look, I’ve still got the paper.” He rummaged in his jacket pocket and pulled out a screwed-up ball of newsprint. It smelt of vinegar and was covered with greasy smudges. “Right lovely bit of haddock it was. From that place on the towpath.”
Lestrade looked him over. He could see grease on his cuff, and as he glanced down at his boots, he could see clay from the river still stuck to them.
“And that’s your excuse, is it? You left the shop at 8pm, took the long way home, and stopped off for a fish supper. Meanwhile, Mr Crabtree was hit on the head at around 8.20pm and you were nowhere nearby? All very convenient.”
“Exactly that, Mr Lestrade”, as he nodded in agreement. “It couldn’t have been me. I wasn’t even there at the time. Mr Potts saw me leave at 8pm, and it’s about 40 minutes’ walk back home via the fish shop. And my landlady told you I was back at 8.40pm didn’t she?”
“Yes, she did”, Lestrade conceded, clearly not happy with where this was leading. “I’m going to have to take a look at your route and see it for myself.”
He stood up and indicated to the policeman at the door.
“Take him back into custody for now, Officer. I’m going for a walk.”
———
Outside the Crabtree pawnbroker shop, Lestrade looked up with an air of despair at the rain falling heavily from the inky black clouds above.
He should have put his new boots on. He’d worn his old pair because he didn’t want to be scraping towpath mud off the soles of his new ones before a meeting with the Superintendent the next day. Which meant that tonight, he would be going home with very soggy feet indeed.
“Ready to go, sir?” asked Constable Perkins, breaking him out of his misery.
“Yes, Constable, let’s get on with it”, he replied. “Watch at the ready?”
“Yes sir. Starting it now”. Perkins was in charge of the station stopwatch and he took his duties seriously, pressing down firmly on the button to start the time counter.
“Let’s be off then” said Lestrade, striding out from under the shop’s overhanging blind and towards the direction of the river. The rain increased in intensity.
———
They reached the fish shack on the towpath after around twenty minutes of walking at a decent pace. As they neared it, Lestrade’s boots took on mud as well as water, making his feet slide around as he walked.
Working at the counter was a young girl, not much older than his own daughter he thought. As she served the customers with their orders, she doused their fish in vinegar and salt and wrapped it up in old newspaper.
Lestrade made his way to the front of the queue. “Chief Inspector Lestrade, Scotland Yard” he announced. “I’m wondering if you know of a fellow called Albert Finch. He says he comes here.”
The girl looked up from her work. “Albert? Thin face?” she asked. Lestrade nodded. “That’s him. Pale, sweats a lot.”
“Oh, I know ‘im alright. He’s a regular ‘e is. Likes vinegar. Lots of it. And haddock, that’s ‘is favourite. Is he in trouble?”
“Maybe, maybe not”, Lestrade responded disappointedly. His stomach growled and he looked at the fish the girl was wrapping in front of him. “Actually, whilst I’m here, can I have one of those?”
Walking back to Constable Perkins with his fish, Lestrade’s enthusiasm dimmed. They were far away from the scene of the crime and he couldn’t see a way around Finch’s alibi. If he was here at the fish shack, then how could he be knocking Crabtree over the head with a lead pipe at his shop?
“What time is it, Perkins?” he asked.
“Around 8.30pm, sir,” he replied. “Another ten minutes or so and we should be at Mr Finch’s lodgings.”
“Well, let’s finish the job,” said Lestrade dejectedly. “And get home before we catch our deaths of pneumonia.”
———
The next morning, Lestrade was at his desk in Scotland Yard bright and early. He’d had a restful sleep, no doubt from the walking and bracing conditions, though he could feel a little tickle appearing in the back of his mouth. Unenthusiastically, he made a mental note to ask his housekeeper to fix him a hot honey drink before bed this evening.
Head down, he barely noticed the visitor entering his office and settling down into the comfy chair in the corner.
“Nice stroll last night, Lestrade?” the visitor asked loudly.
Lestrade jumped out of his chair at the sudden intrusion in the peace and quiet. “Holmes!” he cried, automatically putting his hand to his heart to check his pulse. “How on earth did you get in?”
“I’ve been testing a new type of rubber sole for my boots”, Holmes replied. “They seem to be virtually noise-free, even on wooden floors such as these. I thought it might help in situations where you don’t want to be heard poking around.”
“I’d certainly say they are”, Lestrade said, starting to regain his composure as he sat back down. “Although I don’t fancy them getting into the wrong hands. Our rate of burglaries would be through the roof. Anyway, what brought you here at this time in the morning? It’s barely eleven.”
“I was wondering about the case you were looking into yesterday”, Holmes said. “I had a question.”
“The Crabtree affair? I thought we had our man – Albert Finch – his assistant at the shop”, Lestrade said disappointedly. “But his alibi checks out. He couldn’t have been there at the time of the attack. The custody sergeant is completing his discharge paperwork as we speak.”
“Really?” said Holmes. “Where was he then?”
“At the fish shack on the towpath by the river”, Lestrade replied. “By our reckoning, he couldn’t have attacked Mr Crabtree, at 8.20pm, made it to the fish shack and then returned home to his lodgings by 8.40pm when the landlady said he came in.
“They do a good, battered fish down there if you’re in the area”, he added. “Filled a hole last night.” He patted his tummy as he remembered how well it had gone down.
“Yes, I’ve often availed myself of their cuisine”, Holmes said airily. “Though never on a Monday night.”
“Oh, yes?” said Lestrade distractedly, going back to his paperwork. He had a lot to get through and this wasn’t helping. “Why’s that, then?”
“For the simple fact that they’re closed on a Monday.”
Lestrade paused and looked up.
“Closed, you say?”
“Yes.”
“On a Monday?”
“Yes”, Holmes repeated.
“Every Monday?” Lestrade asked.
“Without fail”, Holmes confirmed.
“But that means…” Lestrade started to say.
“Yes. Yes, it does” Holmes said with a twinkle in his eye.
“But the newspaper in his pocket? The caked-on clay on his boots? And his greasy cuff?” Lestrade asked.
“Perhaps from the night before, especially if he’d checked his route out in advance”, Holmes replied. “And it is terribly hard to get grease stains out of your clothes, especially if you’re hard up and don’t have a housekeeper.”
“Then…he is our man?” Lestrade probed excitedly.
“Yes, I would say that he is”, Holmes confirmed.
Lestrade had never shown as much speed as he did in that instant, jumping up, pushing his chair back and running out of the office down the hallway, bellowing out loud as he went.
“Sergeant!!! Sergeant!! Don’t let that man leave the building!!”
Holmes smiled, took out his pipe and lit the tobacco as he waited for him to return. It was nice to see that Lestrade got the right man occasionally, he thought. Even if he needed a little nudge in the right direction.